Shanghai teachers: education then and now

Five Shanghai educators compare today's school-life to their childhood's

Out with the canings, in with the iPads – the nature of education has changed a lot over the years. Time Out Family asked five educators to compare and contrast school-life now with what it was like when they were young


Steve Jacobi

"steve_wellington_01-0" "steve_wellington_03-0"

Country of origin England
Job title IB Co-ordinator and Director of Culture, Wellington International

Where did you go to school?
Cedarhurst School (junior) and Solihull School (senior), both in the Birmingham area.

What’s your happiest memory from your school days?
Kissing Jane Goldingham during a geography class. We were both seven years old. Mrs Cheeseby saw us, and I (but not Jane) was put in detention. It has to be either this or tying Mark Perkins to his desk during math. Mark was a good friend. We were both eleven and it just seemed a funny thing to do (and it was.) I got a detention for that, too. At one point I held the record for detentions – twenty three consecutive weeks, every Tuesday, 4.15-5.15pm.

How is school different these days to when you were a kid?
There is definitely more pressure now. Well, more pressure to achieve grades, which isn’t quite or even nearly the same thing as getting a proper education.

What were the best things about school back then?
Being able to read many books – I doubt this would have happened if I’d had today’s promiscuous access to technology; playing cricket; liver and onions every Wednesday; a circumscribed tolerance and an understanding of eccentricity; and the fact that school got me out of the house!

Was there anything you particularly disliked about school when you were young?
Swimming lessons; school on Saturdays; the Combined Cadet Force – a bit like the army, though only a bit and mostly the bad bits; having to learn the violin; toilets that were next to the changing rooms; those plastic over-shoes my mum made me wear; Miss Hinks.

What are the things that kids have in school now that you wish you had back then?
The means to watch films in class and, I guess, the opportunity to use technology in general. Though this is a double-edged benefit (as I alluded to above). When I was at school, even the sight of a reel-to-reel tape recorder would cause shuddering expectation and awe.

Did you ever suffer from first-day-of school jitters?
Nope, no jitters. I had an exaggerated and completely misplaced sense of belonging at school.

Did your time at school inspire you to become involved with education?
Yes. I discovered the proverbial ‘love of literature’ when I was 17 and one teacher in particular helped develop that. In addition, I also had a charismatic headmaster who made me understand how important education was, and is. After university, a possibly foolish contempt for other jobs, such as law and advertising, both of which I considered, briefly and painfully, was significant. I ran away from being a grown-up and, I guess, I am still running!

David Chaveriat

"david_concordia-0" "david_concordia_02-0"

Country of origin USA
Current job title Middle School Grade Five teacher, Concordia International School

Where did you go to school?
Chicago St James Lutheran School.

What’s your happiest memory from your school days?
My school was so small and my family so large that when Grades 4, 5 and 6 were combined, there were three of us Chaveriats in one room! All of us brothers looked alike since my dad was a barber. When the teacher howled, ‘Chaveriat, stop that!’ my two older and better behaved brothers, Paul and Jimmy, would politely respond, ‘Yes, Mr Frank,’ even if they were innocent. I would gratefully accept their kindness and smile. This was just one of perks of having older siblings.

How is school different these days compared to when you were a kid?
We came in, we sat down. Our desk tops flipped up and held our books, lunch and supplies like a whale’s belly. And we never worked in groups – how could you move around a 23kg metal desk? The entire approach to discipline was drastically different. Spankings were not at all unusual; the female teachers used rulers and ping pong paddles, while the male teachers preferred belts. One German teacher even had a cricket bat for naughty kids.

What were the best things about school back then?
In 1968, a small carton of milk was three cents and once a week, we got chocolate. I was given twelve cents to take the bus; sometimes I would walk home instead and spend the money at a hotdog stand. Tamales cost exactly 0.12USD. Heavenly!

Was there anything you particularly disliked about school then?
No, I loved school.

What are the things that kids have in school now that you wish you had back then?
Better pens! I mostly used a pencil as a school kid before, eventually, the latest technological advance, a Bic biro, became available. They cost 0.19USD and came in four different colors. Amazing! It was the only
advanced stationary we had other than a compass and protractor.

Did you have first-day-of-school jitters?
My birthday was 2 December and the cutoff was 1 December, but I got into the first grade when I was five without ever attending kindergarten. Thus I was more relieved to be going to school than I was nervous on that first day.

Judy Herde

"fudan_judy_02-0" "fudan_judy_03-0"

Country of origin New Zealand
Job title Grade 3 homeroom teacher at Fudan International School, NET entrance test assessor and elementary school newsletter editor

Where did you go to school?
As a child I lived on a very beautiful 200 acre sheep farm in Ness Valley, Clevedon, which is about an hour’s drive from Auckland. I went to the local county school which was originally a one-room wooden schoolhouse. I would walk a kilometre or so from our farmhouse each morning, up a long gravel road to the main tar sealed road in order to catch the school bus, which began its route from a nearby coastal community further down the valley. The trip took around thirty minutes. It was always fun to clamber aboard and chatter with friends both Maori and European.

What’s your happiest memory from your school days?
Fish and chips wrapped in newspaper on Fridays! I can still smell and taste them when I close my eyes. Calf Club days were also wonderful. One year I took along four small kittens in a wicker basket and won third prize. I felt like I had won the moon! I also loved hot, summery athletic days. My friend Catherine and I used to take turns at coming first in the 50 yard sprint – there were no metric measurements back then!

How is school different these days to when you were a kid?
‘Freedom’, ‘fun’ and ‘innocence’ are the three words that come to mind when I think of my childhood. Kids were kids back then. We simply had fun. There was no pressure to get A grades, wear sunhats, sunblock, bicycle helmets or follow many safety regulations. We climbed trees in the school yard, played softball and marbles and competed with hula hoops. One craze I recall was ‘Swiss skipping’, done with elastic bands around our ankles. We were not afraid of pollution, wars, nuclear disasters, global warming, over population or human rights issues. Life was simple and children could enjoy their childhood.

Class learning was structured but fun, with Janet and John books being common class readers. I remember being read to a lot as a child at school and loving it. Neat handwriting was very important. Even in Math I liked writing my numbers nicely in the squares to get a stamp from my teacher, Miss Jupp, who I was very scared of. Corporal punishment was legal and we accepted it as the norm. Students – even five-year-olds – got the strap, which was made of leather, back in those days. As a joke I called the teacher Miss Pup one day and she took me out the door and strapped my little hand very hard. I cried and cried. I became very afraid of authority figures after that incident. It made me a more anxious child beneath my sunny personality.

What were the best things about school back then?
One of the wonderful things about school back when I was a child was the sense of community. The school was the hub of our rural village and was the focal point for fun, food and friendship. Everyone knew everyone else; people really knew and cared about each other. Teachers were more stable figures in our lives as people didn’t move around so much back then. Teachers used to stay for years in their positions and were very important role models for children, and they knew local families well. Children visited each other’s homes more when I was growing up. Many children only see each other at school in today’s world. I remember engaging in a great deal of social interaction with my peers in activities such as music, singing, playing board and card games or doing crafts or cooking. Visiting other farming families was so common when I was a child, as was playing in the streets of the neighbourhood when we later moved to town.

What are the things kids have today you wish you had back then?
I wish I had been taught more languages as a child. There is so much opportunity for second language learning for the majority of children now. I think I was born to travel, so I’ve needed more languages! I also wish that I’d had the opportunity to travel more as a child, like so many children seem privileged to enjoy today. Robinson Crusoe, by Daniel Defoe, was my absolute favorite book. I was a passionate reader and I used to imagine going on great adventures, and when I grew up I did. I’m glad I didn’t grow up in today’s electronic world.

Did you ever suffer from first-day-of-school jitters?
I sure did! On my first day of school the teacher heavy-handedly plonked me between two children larger than me. I was shy and nervous, so I was too scared to ask either of them to pass me any crayons to help draw my picture. Gladys and Pop were their names and we have since had a good laugh about it as adults.

Kelly Jane Greenfield

"kelly_britannia-0" "kelly_britannia_02-0"

Country of origin England
Current job title Year One teacher, Britannica International School, Shanghai

Where did you go to school?
A small village school. By small I mean there were 100 students across seven year groups. It was called Jolesfield Church of England Primary School in Partridge Green, West Sussex; then to Steyning Grammar School in the next village.

What’s your happiest memory from your school days?
I just loved being at primary school, they were the happiest times of my life. When I was looking back through my old photos I got a feeling of constant excitement, total security and an atmosphere of fun and caring. I still remember some of those teachers today after all this time. There was Mrs Muschin who told us she loved Smarties and came to regret it when she was given giant tubes of the things by every student every summer and Christmas until she retired; and Mrs Williams the Year 6 teacher who had to try and get us ready for leaving to go to Secondary School. They inspired me so much that I never wanted to be anything other than a teacher myself.

How is school different these days compared to when you were a kid?
Jolesfield was a proper village school where everyone knew everyone else and I feel I was extremely lucky to have that small nurturing environment; I don’t think that is very common these days. Jolesfield is still there but has expanded from one form entry to three and the huge green playing field we had is now full of static classrooms. I think there is a lot more pressure on kids these days and too much testing. When I was at school the only thing I had to worry about was the weekly times table and spelling tests!

What were the best things about school back then?
I remember my teachers chose what we learnt about and everything was done in a topic-centered way. My favourites were: Romans in Year 3, Tudors in Year 5, Planets in Year 6. We seemed to be allowed to be much more creative than we are these days and did projects that lasted weeks. I still have my old school books and projects, everything bound and mounted by myself.

Was there anything you particularly disliked about school when you were young?
No, not really. I didn’t particularly look forward to the weekly times table test and I remember having to listen to my times table tape every morning while I was having my porridge for breakfast. I still never got all the questions right!

What are the things that kids have in school now that you wish you had back then?
I suppose I would have to say technology. I remember our primary school getting their first computer. It was a BBC Micro computer and was on a trolley with wheels so it could be moved into any classroom. The printer was massive and you had to feed in a huge wedge of paper, the type with holes all the way down the edge that we used to make bracelets and things. But saying that, I don’t feel like I missed out on anything. I think perhaps we rely too heavily on technology nowadays.

Did you ever suffer from first-day-of-school jitters?
Not especially; it was a small village school so you already knew all the other students as you had all gone to playschool together. You also knew all the teachers as you would see them in the village shop every weekend, there was nothing unknown to worry about. Leaving the village school to go to secondary school in the next town over – that was scary.

Rus Ekkel

"rus_ekkel_biss-0" "rus_ekkel_biss-2"

Country of origin England
Current job title Film, Media & English teacher at the British International School, Shanghai (Puxi campus)

Where did you go to school?
Don’t tell anyone, but I went to Hounslow in west London. It’s near Twickenham, but is a lot less civilised.

What’s your happiest memory from your school days?
Raising several hundred pounds for our school charity week with a sketch show I wrote and co-starred in, in which I did impressions of our headmaster and head of languages and fulfilled my dreams by dressing up as Batman! Also: A-level results day when I got what I needed to get into the university that I wanted. Although my joy lasted only a few minutes – I found out that most of my peer group failed and that my best friend wouldn’t be going to university with me.

How is school different these days compared to when you were a kid?
It’s really quite amazing to realise that the answer to any conceivable question is simply just a few strokes of the keyboard away. Sports now seem to take on a greater priority, while teaching styles have become more relaxed and less dictatorial than before.

What were the best things about school back then?
At my school: butterscotch pudding with custard, a once-a-term treat that caused enormous excitement in the canteen and a race for seconds. I still remember the teachers who inspired me – Mr Quirk, whose quiet authority made me eager to please in history and my Year 8 English teacher Mr Tanner, who one lunchtime pulled me down a flight of stairs and into the library, pushing a copy of Catch 22 into my hands to nurture my writing. I hope someone will have a similar fond memory of me one day, but without all the pulling and pushing, of course!

Was there anything you particularly disliked about school when you were young?
As a rather overweight child with an odd name I discovered early on that school children aren’t all nice and can make life a challenge for the unconventional. I think we live in more accepting and enlightened times now. Also, the smell of our school’s PE changing rooms still haunts my dreams.

What are the things that kids have in school now that you wish you had back then?
I would love to be a student now, with technology being so readily available. I would certainly have enrolled for my own IB film class! We didn’t have the technology back then to film and edit our own movies, so I mourn for all my lost masterpieces. I think modern students are very lucky to have such a range of subject options as well as easy access to worldwide resources.

Did you ever suffer from first-day-of-school jitters?
I would say that I was probably as nervous as anyone on my first day of secondary school. But I had an older brother there to look after me – this was extremely helpful in Hounslow, which isn’t ever going to feature as a honeymoon destination.

Comments